**Video Club Current Video** Dare to Disagree - Margrett Heffernan

Video Link

Most people instinctively avoid conflict, but as Margaret Heffernan shows us, good disagreement is central to progress. She illustrates (sometimes counterintuitively) how the best partners aren’t echo chambers – and how great research teams, relationships and businesses allow people to deeply disagree.

This video was recommended to me by AI whilst entering in a few thought leaders and videos and asking it to find others I should follow

2 Likes

Love this Alan - even better that its a quick 12m.
I love the “dare to have such collaborators” and “see conflict as thinking and get really good at it”.
Matt brought up something similar when he asked “how do we deal with conflict” but this takes it a step further, how do we actively create conflict/“thinking” to think deeper, solve more problems and challenge ourselves further!
I’ve told AI to stop agreeing with me… but after this I think I’ll set it up to actively disagree and challenge me. Happy to be someone’s “conflict” buddy and try this out.
Thank you for sharing this!

2 Likes

wow this video is very inspiring. Even though it’s from 14 years ago it’s still valid.

I was one of the people who would avoid conflicts in life as much as I could and am still a little avoiding sometimes. Conflicts require lots of work to go into especially at work but outcomes are worth it for the good conflicts. Keep challenging yourself with good conflicts and improve your work and life :slight_smile:

2 Likes

I disagree! You’re all wrong! And I can prove it.

Alright, no I can’t. Great vid - I’d not seen this one. Love the call to ‘Moral Courage’ at the end - that’s what makes it hard, but the more you exercise that muscle, the easier it gets. And as someone who’s always going on about Transparency and Openness, I was really struck by her assertion that ‘Openness alone can’t drive change’. It needs to be paired with that moral courage to tackle the difficult thing that transparency has highlighted.

There are some of these neat encapsulations of concepts in under 15 min videos that are totally timeless. I guarantee you that Alice would have recognised it in the 50s, we recognise it today, and it’ll ring true in another 50 years time!

1 Like

‘Seeing conflict as thinking’ - I really like this. I am a massive fan of Patrick Lencioni 5 Dysfunctions of a team and the ‘fear of conflict’ step, it really resonated with me.
The stat about fear of conflict is horrid but so common, especially with the term ‘whistle blower’ being used for challenging the system.

University of Delft getting people to stand up to 5 statements they are willing to defend - I wonder how we could implement this, possibly as a leadership tool to potentially create a reverse mentoring exercise.

It ticks off quite a few boxes for me about openness not being enough, challenge is not enough. Leaders claiming they are open or that their door is always open is not enough. We need conflict for the benefit of shared learning

I like this, and think she frames it well, so I see it as a useful prompt. I feel like I might need to dig in to this more, because the brevity of the talk has left me feeling slightly 'Well, Duh!". It feels obvious to me that people challenging your ideas/ thought processes helps to make them stronger and better thought out. Though if setting things out like this helps people feel empowered to find people who constructively challenge then it can’t be a bad thing

1 Like